Dhamma Greetings,
this is about, as the title suggests, doing formal meditation in groups. As far as I can remember the Suttas, I never read, that the Buddha recommended to sit in groups. Only suggestions to sit at the foot of trees or empty huts, but never 'groups'. But meditating in groups is what all the Sanghas I know are doing. Compared to the Suttas -- is there something wrong with that?
Kind regards
formal meditation in groups
-
- Posts: 1092
- Joined: Fri May 01, 2015 3:21 pm
Re: formal meditation in groups
There are recommendations to mediate alone as a hermit. However, the suttas are also full of references to the Buddha mediating with others and the early sangha and assemblies meditating together. It was clearly the practice to have long group retreats in the rainy season for the sangha. Although there was an early controversy over which was preferable (hermits vs. monastics) I strongly doubt you could say there is anything wrong in group meditation from a sutta view
- Bhikkhu Pesala
- Posts: 4647
- Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 8:17 pm
Re: formal meditation in groups
Take account of the fact that many forest monks and nuns in the Buddha's time were already Noble Ones, and were developing concentration for higher stages.
Nowadays, most are not so pure-hearted and may need some group support to keep them practising consistently. Most meditation centres have group sittings and meditators are expect to spend most of their time in the meditation hall together with other meditators. If left too much to their own devices, they will become negligent.
Nowadays, most are not so pure-hearted and may need some group support to keep them practising consistently. Most meditation centres have group sittings and meditators are expect to spend most of their time in the meditation hall together with other meditators. If left too much to their own devices, they will become negligent.
Blog • Pāli Fonts • In This Very Life • Buddhist Chronicles • Software (Upasampadā: 24th June, 1979)
Re: formal meditation in groups
There is a Sutta to support Ven. Pesala's statement.
Buddha ask a particular monk not to go to solitary meditation until his virtues are perfected.
Buddha ask a particular monk not to go to solitary meditation until his virtues are perfected.
“As the lamp consumes oil, the path realises Nibbana”
- Goofaholix
- Posts: 4030
- Joined: Sun Nov 15, 2009 3:49 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: formal meditation in groups
I think some things can best be left to common sense, no need for it to be explicitly in the suttas, if you are together with a group of like minded people why wouldn't you sit together. There is no sutta recommending a toilet break before sitting either but given the opportunity I make damned sure that I do.
Pronouns (no self / not self)
“Peace is within oneself to be found in the same place as agitation and suffering. It is not found in a forest or on a hilltop, nor is it given by a teacher. Where you experience suffering, you can also find freedom from suffering. Trying to run away from suffering is actually to run toward it.”
― Ajahn Chah
“Peace is within oneself to be found in the same place as agitation and suffering. It is not found in a forest or on a hilltop, nor is it given by a teacher. Where you experience suffering, you can also find freedom from suffering. Trying to run away from suffering is actually to run toward it.”
― Ajahn Chah
Re: formal meditation in groups
Greetings, SarathW,
Kind Regards
do you remember, which Sutta that was?SarathW wrote:There is a Sutta to support Ven. Pesala's statement.
Buddha ask a particular monk not to go to solitary meditation until his virtues are perfected.
Kind Regards
Re: formal meditation in groups
On the other hand -- meditation retreats focusing on developing jhana-type concentration -- having been to many such retreats (and under three different teacher-groups), and witnessing the difficulties of progressing, in my own experience and many others'.
In my own case, substantial progress was made possible by taking the sitting sessions OUT of the common hall, into the bedroom, or tent, or (at one center) a remote and rarely occupied "meditation cottage". Then:
1) one can go at one's own pace, e.g. longer sessions to work with the deeper concentration that naturally comes after, say, 40-50 minutes. Retreats that use 45 minute sessions -- forget it. Even 1-hour sessions break-up just as the point where deepening progress is being reached. ("Milage may vary" as to the durations mentioned here; after getting to know absorption better, my experience is that it's possible to get to "access" in 10-20 minutes, under good conditions. Even under less ideal conditions -- particularly unsettled mind coming in -- getting there at by 40-50 minutes is quite reliable.)
2) one is free of the ubiquitous disturbances of people coming and going; squeaking chairs; coughing, nose blowing; etc. (Edit: Reminds me of a theme in the Culasunnata Sutta -- there still will be "disturbance", but the degree can be crucial for concentration.)
Clearly, the sutta-instructions recommend actual (physical) solitude as condition for developing the mental "seclusion" that's gateway to absorption.
It should be possible, at the meditation centers I've been at, to arrange more private spaces for sitting -- in private sleeping quarters, or out-lying shelters.
In my own case, substantial progress was made possible by taking the sitting sessions OUT of the common hall, into the bedroom, or tent, or (at one center) a remote and rarely occupied "meditation cottage". Then:
1) one can go at one's own pace, e.g. longer sessions to work with the deeper concentration that naturally comes after, say, 40-50 minutes. Retreats that use 45 minute sessions -- forget it. Even 1-hour sessions break-up just as the point where deepening progress is being reached. ("Milage may vary" as to the durations mentioned here; after getting to know absorption better, my experience is that it's possible to get to "access" in 10-20 minutes, under good conditions. Even under less ideal conditions -- particularly unsettled mind coming in -- getting there at by 40-50 minutes is quite reliable.)
2) one is free of the ubiquitous disturbances of people coming and going; squeaking chairs; coughing, nose blowing; etc. (Edit: Reminds me of a theme in the Culasunnata Sutta -- there still will be "disturbance", but the degree can be crucial for concentration.)
Clearly, the sutta-instructions recommend actual (physical) solitude as condition for developing the mental "seclusion" that's gateway to absorption.
It should be possible, at the meditation centers I've been at, to arrange more private spaces for sitting -- in private sleeping quarters, or out-lying shelters.
Re: formal meditation in groups
Sorry I can't recall it.mirco wrote:Greetings, SarathW,do you remember, which Sutta that was?SarathW wrote:There is a Sutta to support Ven. Pesala's statement.
Buddha ask a particular monk not to go to solitary meditation until his virtues are perfected.
Kind Regards
“As the lamp consumes oil, the path realises Nibbana”
Re: formal meditation in groups
http://obo.genaud.net/backmatter/append ... /upali.htmSarathW wrote:Sorry I can't recall it.mirco wrote:Greetings, SarathW,do you remember, which Sutta that was?SarathW wrote:There is a Sutta to support Ven. Pesala's statement.
Buddha ask a particular monk not to go to solitary meditation until his virtues are perfected.
Kind Regards
At the request of the Sakyan youths, the Buddha ordained Upali before them all, so that their pride might be humbled.. . When Upali went to the Buddha for an exercise for meditation, he asked that he might be allowed to dwell in the forest. But the Buddha would not agree, for if Upali went into the forest he would learn only meditation, while, if he remained amongst men, he would have knowledge both of meditation and of the word of the Dhamma. Upali accepted the Buddha's advice and, practicing insight, in due course won arahantship. The Buddha himself taught Upali the whole of the Vinaya Pitaka.
- Bhikkhu Pesala
- Posts: 4647
- Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 8:17 pm
Re: formal meditation in groups
I suspect that Sarath was thinking of the Meghiya Sutta
Blog • Pāli Fonts • In This Very Life • Buddhist Chronicles • Software (Upasampadā: 24th June, 1979)
Re: formal meditation in groups
Dhamma Greetings Ven. Pesala,
This was helpful. Thank you.Bhikkhu Pesala wrote:Take account of the fact that many forest monks and nuns in the Buddha's time were already Noble Ones, and were developing concentration for higher stages.
Nowadays, most are not so pure-hearted and may need some group support to keep them practising consistently. Most meditation centres have group sittings and meditators are expect to spend most of their time in the meditation hall together with other meditators. If left too much to their own devices, they will become negligent.
Last edited by mirco on Mon Sep 12, 2016 1:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: formal meditation in groups
Dhamma Greetings,
Thanks!Bhikkhu Pesala wrote:I suspect that Sarath was thinking of the Meghiya Sutta
Last edited by mirco on Tue Sep 13, 2016 4:47 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: formal meditation in groups
Dhamma Greetings cjmacie,
Kind Regards
actually, that is how the schedule of these retreats are.cjmacie wrote:On the other hand -- meditation retreats focusing on developing jhana-type concentration -- having been to many such retreats (and under three different teacher-groups), and witnessing the difficulties of progressing, in my own experience and many others'.
In my own case, substantial progress was made possible by taking the sitting sessions OUT of the common hall, into the bedroom, or tent, or (at one center) a remote and rarely occupied "meditation cottage". Then:
1) one can go at one's own pace, e.g. longer sessions to work with the deeper concentration that naturally comes after, say, 40-50 minutes. Retreats that use 45 minute sessions -- forget it. Even 1-hour sessions break-up just as the point where deepening progress is being reached. ("Milage may vary" as to the durations mentioned here; after getting to know absorption better, my experience is that it's possible to get to "access" in 10-20 minutes, under good conditions. Even under less ideal conditions -- particularly unsettled mind coming in -- getting there at by 40-50 minutes is quite reliable.)
[...]
It should be possible, at the meditation centers I've been at, to arrange more private spaces for sitting -- in private sleeping quarters, or out-lying shelters.
Kind Regards
-
- Posts: 10263
- Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 10:32 am
- Location: Andromeda looks nice
Re: formal meditation in groups
I am mostly a solitary meditator, but I also appreciate regular group meditation with a local sangha. Regularity of practice seems to be the important factor.mirco wrote:Dhamma Greetings,
this is about, as the title suggests, doing formal meditation in groups. As far as I can remember the Suttas, I never read, that the Buddha recommended to sit in groups. Only suggestions to sit at the foot of trees or empty huts, but never 'groups'. But meditating in groups is what all the Sanghas I know are doing. Compared to the Suttas -- is there something wrong with that?
Kind regards
Buddha save me from new-agers!
Re: formal meditation in groups
Thank you Bhante.Bhikkhu Pesala wrote:I suspect that Sarath was thinking of the Meghiya Sutta
Yes it is the Sutta I was thinking of.
“As the lamp consumes oil, the path realises Nibbana”