Zen Vs Therevada

[Sobeh]

Are there extant comparisons of their Vinayas?

[tiltbillings]

Are there extant comparisons of their Vinayas?

Whose Vinaya? Japanese Zen does not have a Vinaya.

[Sobeh]

Japanese Zen does not have a Vinaya.

I expected something.

[tiltbillings]

Japanese Zen does not have a Vinaya.

I expected something.

There is a fairly complicated history around that. Part of it has to do with the japanese government putting an end to the Vinaya. Other "Zen" school monks do follow Vinaya rules. There are extensive comparative studies of the Vinayas. If Ven Paññāsikhara were still posting here, he could direct you to them.

[jcsuperstar]

if you take the Thai forest tradition of the 20th century and compare it to some zen, you'll get many similarities. some think that maybe this is because Chan monks may have wandered into thailand and that Thai thudong monks may have bumped into Chan monks on their journeys as well. also Thai Buddhism especially in the north and north east (where we get most of our famous forest monks) prior to modernization was an area with many many different Buddhist groups, (in Thai nikaya) now we just have the 2: dhammayut and mahanikaya, but the reason it is called the maha nikaya is because it is made up of all those other nikayas, 100 years ago or so there where 18 in chaing mai alone, all with their own customs and practices. Thai Buddhism is by no means a monolithic institution now, but compared to the past it may seem so. anyways what this may point to is that at some point in the past a Chan (zen) influence may have been introduced into Thai Buddhism. also yogacara ideas may have been introduced (or the fact that zen has some of these may explain the similarities too?).

and as for zen, my personal views on the school is that it didn't start out as a Mahayana school. Bodhidharma was from southern India, and traveled to shaolin temple, a "hinayana" temple at the time. the idea that he taught the lankavatara sutra is odd, as he takes on students, trains them, then only as he is leaving them, fully trained, does he mention anything about this sutra. seems like something just tacked on.
also in Dogen's works he has a different take on arahants than is standard Mahayana but whatever after 1500 plus years of cultural and mahayana influence it matters little . but there are some similarities.

[PeterB]

Japanese Zen does not have a Vinaya.

I expected something.

The Soto school founded by Jiyu Kennett in the west follows the Vinaya. I think in order to do so it was necessary for them to receive initial ordination from an authentic source. I dont recall of the details off hand.

[jcsuperstar]

Japanese Zen does not have a Vinaya.

I expected something.

The Soto school founded by Jiyu Kennett in the west follows the Vinaya. I think in order to do so it was necessary for them to receive initial ordination from an authentic source. I dont recall of the details off hand.

i cant find any info on it

[PeterB]

No, I checked once before...I dimly remember it all happening at the time, and the report in the Buddhist Societys " Middle Way" journal...but I dont remember the details. I could ask So-On Mann over at ZFI. She is knowledgeable about Jiyu Kennett.

[jcsuperstar]

i used to wonder why the Japanese sangha didn't just go ordain in a Chinese or Theravada lineage, and reintroduce the classic monastic institutions, seems simple enough right? but then i realized after spending time with Japanese Buddhists, that my view is just that of an outsider and they are for the most part perfectly happy with their forms of Buddhism.

[PeterB]

I think it may have been like that with Jiyu Kennett JC. It could even have been a Sri Lankan connection...So-On might know.

[tiltbillings]

i used to wonder why the Japanese sangha didn't just go ordain in a Chinese or Theravada lineage, . . . .

Tradition.

Chinese Ch'an I do believe functions in a Vinaya lineage.

[jcsuperstar]

i used to wonder why the Japanese sangha didn't just go ordain in a Chinese or Theravada lineage, . . . .

Chinese Ch'an I do believe functions in a Vinaya lineage.

yes it does

Tradition.

well it worked for them, and not in that way tibetan Buddhists say "i know Tibetan Buddhism is true, because it works" because i have never understood what that meant, what i mean is it has worked as a vehicle for carrying cultural norms as a means of comfort through disasters, wars, etc. it's tied up into what it means to be Japanese, it holds a sense of identity. it's hard to change something like that.

[PeterB]

Well I was wrong basically....

So-On tells me that the Jiyu Kennett folk are required to be celebate but do not and never have followed the Vinaya.
I dont know where I got that idea from...

[Monkey Mind]

A friend of mine is a Soto Zen monk, and her group is traveling to China in the Fall to spend some time in a Chan monastery. Because they are not Vinaya monks, the Zen monks will not be wearing their robes and will be considered lay civilians.

My friend was surprised to learn that entertainment was against the rules, and was amused by the requirement of sleeping in low, uncomfortable beds. Monks in her Zendo store and cook food for themselves (although the emphasis is on community meals.)

[Monkey Mind]

Which reminds me: Gil Fronsdale has a number of Dharma talk podcasts at both Zencast.org and IMS. He was a Soto Zen monk and Abbot of a monastery, but also studied Vipassana for many years in Theravadan countries. Often in his talks, he will compare and differentiate the Zen and the Theravada. Seems like a good resource to the OP.