Bhikkhuni Ordination:
Discouraged by : The Blessed One Buddha, The Greatest Ascetic Maha Kassapa Thero, All the Arahants of The First Council except Ananda Thero
Encouraged by : Maha Pajapati Gotami Theri (before arahantship), The Greatest Scholar Ananda Thero (before arahantship)
Modern Days:
Discouraged by : All the Supreme Leaders of Sangha, Vast Majority of Sangha, Ajahn Chah Group Sangha
Encouraged by : Ajahn Brahm, Ajahn Sujato, Several Western Bhikkhus, Self Proclaimed Bhikkhunis, Modern Feminists
You yourself decide who knows Dhamma well.
Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
- JamesTheGiant
- Posts: 2157
- Joined: Fri Jan 02, 2015 8:41 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
I suggest you follow the Buddha. He ordained women, and supported the ordination of women. True, at the beginning he was reluctant, but after some persuading by Ananda he became a strong supporter of bhikkhunis:
Mara once appeared before the Buddha and asked him to pass from the world because too many people were becoming liberated. The Buddha responded, “I will not pass away until I have established a fourfold sangha,”
That's (1) Monks (2) Nuns (3) Laymen (4) Laywomen to make a fourfold sangha.
Follow what the Buddha said, don't follow other monks and modern sangha officials.
Mara once appeared before the Buddha and asked him to pass from the world because too many people were becoming liberated. The Buddha responded, “I will not pass away until I have established a fourfold sangha,”
That's (1) Monks (2) Nuns (3) Laymen (4) Laywomen to make a fourfold sangha.
Follow what the Buddha said, don't follow other monks and modern sangha officials.
- DNS
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17230
- Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
- Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
- Contact:
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
It's not as simple as that outline you made. The Buddha did support bhikkhuni ordination. He did grant the going forth to Maha-Pajapati and she became an arahant in the saffron robes.
Some modern Buddhists support bhikkhuni ordination and some oppose it. It centers more around legalistic concerns about the double-ordination ceremony since the original bhikkhuni Sangha died out in year 1017, not about if bhikkhunis were ever legitimate or not.
Some modern Buddhists support bhikkhuni ordination and some oppose it. It centers more around legalistic concerns about the double-ordination ceremony since the original bhikkhuni Sangha died out in year 1017, not about if bhikkhunis were ever legitimate or not.
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
Yes I agree. He supported after an initial reluctance.JamesTheGiant wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 7:18 pm He ordained women, and supported the ordination of women.
JamesTheGiant wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 7:18 pm True, at the beginning he was reluctant, but after some persuading by Ananda he became a strong supporter of bhikkhunis:
We can't say he became a 'strong' supporter. The Buddha will not become a strong supporter for a mission which he initially reluctant.
Yes. Bhikkhunis were part of fourfold sangha. It's not the case here. I'm talking about encouragement and discouragement.JamesTheGiant wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 7:18 pm The Buddha responded, “I will not pass away until I have established a fourfold sangha,”
That's (1) Monks (2) Nuns (3) Laymen (4) Laywomen to make a fourfold sangha.
We should consider everything the Blessed One said about women. Not only one thing.
Eg: Initial discouragement, Later approval, Imposing garu dhamma, Stating the sasanaa will be half cut, Refusal of equal status by Gotami theri.
And we should consider ancient Arahant's behavior.
Eg. Mahakassapa thero and the first sangha council's allegation on initiating bhikkhuni ordination, Ananda thero's defence
You can't ignore other monks or modern sangha completely. If we do so we have to ignore modern bhikkhuni supporting monks before we ignore other sangha.JamesTheGiant wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 7:18 pm don't follow other monks and modern sangha officials.
Answered above.
Here I'm talking about encouragement and discouragement. Not about their legality.
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
- DNS
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17230
- Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
- Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
- Contact:
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
But that is the reason for their discouragement; i.e., the legality issue. Those opposed (discourage) to the bhikkhuni ordinations going on right now say that it is not valid since there was no double-ordination ceremony. There are double-ordination ceremonies going on right now, but they argue that the original double ceremony (that revived the bhikkhunis, back in 1996-2002) used Mahayana nuns (ordination by nuns, followed by monks from Theravada), so that the subsequent ordinations are invalid (in their opinion) due to the Theravada nuns not having a proper ordination.
Those in favor (encourage) bhikkhuni ordination argue that this is what the Buddha wanted, there was always the wish for a four-fold Sangha and there is no problem with using the Mahayana nuns in the beginning since they can trace their lineage at least as far back as Dharmaguptaka (which was one of the 18 to 20 early schools with Theravada).
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
If there is an issue about legality and if the sangha don't accept the bhiikhuni ordination, why does someone re-initiate bhiikhuni ordination by being disobedient to sangha decisions? We can see clear feminism in it.
Why does someone need to keep doing what sangha asked them not to do ?
This is a clear indicator of opposing sangha.
Will a person opposing sangha attain nibbana?
Why does someone need to keep arguing with sangha ?
Why does someone need to keep doing what sangha asked them not to do ?
This is a clear indicator of opposing sangha.
Will a person opposing sangha attain nibbana?
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
- DNS
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17230
- Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
- Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
- Contact:
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
We don't have a Pope of Theravada Buddhism. Some monasteries and monks perform ordinations of bhikkhunis and some do not.
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
The absence of a single leader becomes an issue only if some theravada sangha nikayas accept bhikkhuni ordination.
But there is no theravada nikaya in this world which accepts the bhikkhuni ordination.
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
- cappuccino
- Posts: 12977
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 1:45 am
- Contact:
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
I would think blocking anyone, male or female,
is evil.
is evil.
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
Definitely. Any Buddhist knows blocking is unwholesome.
But this is not about blocking. This is about whether we encourage or not.
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
- DNS
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17230
- Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
- Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
- Contact:
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
Bhante Henepola Gunaratana regularly performs bhikkhuni ordinations and he is the head of Siam Nikaya, North America region. And several monasteries throughout Sri Lanka ordain bhikkhunis, so I imagine most or all do so with the approval of their Nikaya ordination lineage.
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
They do it without their nikaya's approval.DNS wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 8:49 pm Bhante Henepola Gunaratana regularly performs bhikkhuni ordinations and he is the head of Siam Nikaya, North America region. And several monasteries throughout Sri Lanka ordain bhikkhunis, so I imagine most or all do so with the approval of their Nikaya ordination lineage.
island.lk
"We have to abide by the decision of Mahanayakes’ – Commissioner General
"I am aware that there are issues, but with due respect to the wishes of the three nikayas, we cannot accord recognition to them as Bhikkhunis", says Nimal Kotawalagedara, Commissioner General of Buddhist Affairs.
.. as a Theravada Buddhist country, Sri Lanka considers the Bhikkhunis Order defunct after the Polonnaruwa era, he elaborated.
"As the Buddhist Affairs department, we have to abide by the decisions of the Mahanayakes of the three Nikayas, who consider the Bhikkhuni Order not restorable after it disappeared during ancient times", he said.
"There may be pros and cons, but we have to abide by decisions of the Mahanayakes", the Commissioner General added.
Last edited by thang on Thu Sep 20, 2018 9:09 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
Is this supported by Vinaya? Isn't it Vinaya that should administer monastic affairs?thang wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 9:03 pmThey do it without their nikaya's approval.DNS wrote: ↑Thu Sep 20, 2018 8:49 pm Bhante Henepola Gunaratana regularly performs bhikkhuni ordinations and he is the head of Siam Nikaya, North America region. And several monasteries throughout Sri Lanka ordain bhikkhunis, so I imagine most or all do so with the approval of their Nikaya ordination lineage.island.lk
"I am aware that there are issues, but with due respect to the wishes of the three nikayas, we cannot accord recognition to them as Bhikkhunis", says Nimal Kotawalagedara, Commissioner General of Buddhist Affairs.
.. as a Theravada Buddhist country, Sri Lanka considers the Bhikkhunis Order defunct after the Polonnaruwa era, he elaborated.
"As the Buddhist Affairs department, we have to abide by the decisions of the Mahanayakes of the three Nikayas, who consider the Bhikkhuni Order not restorable after it disappeared during ancient times", he said.
"There may be pros and cons, but we have to abide by decisions of the Mahanayakes", the Commissioner General added.
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
Out of the topic question.
Lay officials cannot issue identity cards for the self proclaimed bhikkhunis who are not recognized by the sangha.
"Bhikkhus, whatever the Tathāgata speaks, _ all that is just so and NOT otherwise."
Re: Discouraging and Encouraging Bhikkhuni Ordination
That doesn't comply with Vinaya, as laid down by the Buddha does it? Who created this bureaucracy? What is the basis. And what is the motivation?