Some people in the no-self camp think this same way: "If you don't say there is no soul, this means you're saying there is a soul." Well, the targets of this "reasoning" do expose themselves eventually. Ven T's famous not-self strategy is supposed to point the way to the post-mo...

First off, what is the distinction between atthi and honti? It seems that hoti/hū is derived from bhavati/bhū ... so, what's the distinction between the three then? "Bhavati" has "to become" included in the definition, from what I've found, whereas the other two are merely "...

1. I have to confess i still don't get the dwellings bit. May i trouble you to dwell on it and elaborate? Are you saying that viharati is a verbal noun? That is unlikely, as a form is available in Pali to convey this. It looked like "dwelling" was being used to mean a participial action -...

1. I have to confess i still don't get the dwellings bit. May i trouble you to dwell on it and elaborate? Are you saying that viharati is a verbal noun? That is unlikely, as a form is available in Pali to convey this. 2a See the CPD entry 2b You'll have to read the entire Timeless Model of PS thread...

I'm a bit confused as to how the sentence works without containing a verb, even though I get the meaning of the Pāḷi after looking up the words. In the Pāḷi construction, it's that three causes, kammas, arise from. Why not a verb instead of a noun? Hope the query is no longer stale, but as to why t...

Some people in the no-self camp think this same way: "If you don't say there is no soul, this means you're saying there is a soul." Well, the targets of this "reasoning" do expose themselves eventually. Ven T's famous not-self strategy is supposed to point the way to the post-mo...

Huh?

Reasoning = argument = premises + conclusion (hopefully coupled with a logical operator for the conclusion to be derived logically from the premises).

Your example comes nowhere near to being an argument.

Anyone? What is your point? Absence of evidence is evidence of absence? I can't think of the fancy name for this particular fallacy you are applying. The Buddha didn't mention Flying Spaghetti monsters either... :anjali: Mike Hmm, is he saying - "If there is evidence, then the soul exists. The...

It might be useful to analyse the pericope in detail: So cakkhunā rūpaṃ disvā na nimittaggāhī hoti ­nānub­yañ­janag­gāhī. Yat­vādhika­ra­ṇa­menaṃ cakkhundriyaṃ asaṃvutaṃ viharantaṃ abhij­jhā­do­manassā pāpakā akusalā dhammā anvāssaveyyuṃ tassa saṃvarāya paṭipajjati, rakkhati cakkhundriyaṃ, cakkhund...

I don't think anyone is doubting the importance and relevance of teeth-gnashing, when one is desperate enough to reach for the last resort. I doubt the importance and relevance of teeth-clenching/toungue-pressing it to some extent. Personally, I have never found it to be effective. I find breath-ob...

Could you explain your points pls? I can't follow.

L.N. wrote:...

Hi L.N.

I don't think anyone is doubting the importance and relevance of teeth-gnashing, when one is desperate enough to reach for the last resort.

But the question remains - is that the establishment of mindfulness?

As far as watching, it is better to watch a good thing, than a bad one.[ The process is the same; but with less dukkha. And you will see them "better" and "truer", (if there are no hindrances,) say the suttas. So maybe for some people, there will be a little (or a lot of) aversi...

:woohoo: Again that assumption that "I don't uderstand the grammar of the suttas"; Well, my "woohoo" was not an indictment of your grasp of grammar, but of your eel-wriggling. But on the subject of grammar, didn't you yourself concede this - and picking on me, on the fact that I...

spacenick wrote: ...