Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Exploring the Dhamma, as understood from the perspective of the ancient Pali commentaries.
User avatar
dhammabum
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2009 1:41 am

Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by dhammabum »

Thanissaro Bhikkhu makes mention that the Buddha didn't hand down a mechanism in which to revive the Sangha if it ever died, such as the Bhikkhuni Sangha. What structural constraints described in the Vinaya prevents its revival?

http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/thai ... namic.html
The Theravadin Bhikkhuni Sangha, the nuns' order founded by the Buddha, died out because of war and famine almost a millennium ago, and the Buddha provided no mechanism for its revival. (The same holds true for the Bhikkhu Sangha, or monks' order. If it ever dies out, there is no way it can be revived.) Thus the only ordination opportunities open to women in Theravadin countries are as lay nuns, observing eight or ten precepts.
Thanks
User avatar
Ben
Posts: 18438
Joined: Wed Dec 31, 2008 12:49 am
Location: kanamaluka

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by Ben »

Since the OP has asked the question within the context of the ancient texts, this thread has been moved to the Classical Theravada forum.

Please ensure your posts comply with the guidelines for this forum.
kind regards,

Ben
“No lists of things to be done. The day providential to itself. The hour. There is no later. This is later. All things of grace and beauty such that one holds them to one's heart have a common provenance in pain. Their birth in grief and ashes.”
- Cormac McCarthy, The Road

Learn this from the waters:
in mountain clefts and chasms,
loud gush the streamlets,
but great rivers flow silently.
- Sutta Nipata 3.725

Compassionate Hands Foundation (Buddhist aid in Myanmar) • Buddhist Global ReliefUNHCR

e: [email protected]..
User avatar
DNS
Site Admin
Posts: 17169
Joined: Tue Dec 30, 2008 4:15 am
Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, Estados Unidos de América
Contact:

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by DNS »

dhammabum wrote:Thanissaro Bhikkhu makes mention that the Buddha didn't hand down a mechanism in which to revive the Sangha if it ever died, such as the Bhikkhuni Sangha. What structural constraints described in the Vinaya prevents its revival?
According to the Tipitaka, there must be a quorum of nuns and monks to ordain a new nun (bhikkhuni). If there are no nuns around, there can be no new ordinations.

However, Maha Pajapati Gotami was ordained by the Buddha with no other nun at the "ceremony". Current bhikkhunis use a line traced back to Dharmagupta which is believed to be traced back to the original, others disagree. Here are a few relevant quotes from the Suttas:

The Buddha was asked in so many words, "is there even one woman nun who is fully enlightened?" The Buddha responded, "There are not only one hundred . . . or five hundred, but far more bhikkhunis, my disciples, who by realizing for themselves with direct knowledge here and now enter upon and abide in the deliverance of mind and deliverance by wisdom . . ." Sutta 73 Majjhima Nikaya and also in other suttas too.

I will not take final Nibbana till I have nuns and female disciples who are accomplished, till I have laymen and laywomen followers who are accomplished.” Digha Nikaya 16.3.8

After I am gone, the Sangha, if it wants, may abolish the lesser and minor training rules.” Digha Nikaya 16

Although, Ananda did not remember or know what the "minor" rules were and it was decided at the First Council to keep them all. It is not known if the requirement for a quorum of nuns is considered a minor rule or not.
User avatar
pilgrim
Posts: 1679
Joined: Mon Oct 19, 2009 2:56 pm

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by pilgrim »

Its already been revived for about 2 decades now. I think a question of greater relevance is will it be accepted? As far as lay people go, I hardly see any opposition.
User avatar
lyndon taylor
Posts: 1835
Joined: Mon May 02, 2011 11:41 pm
Location: Redlands, US occupied Northern Mexico
Contact:

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by lyndon taylor »

Forgive me if I'm slightly off topic, but I was witness, here in Southern California, to ordained nuns over 20 years ago. WATBUDDHAGODOM was an interfaith south east Asian Buddhist Temple founded by a Lunpo from Vietnam, came as a refugee to Thailand, and settled In Highland California and built two small temples on a large block of land, now unfortuanetly a housing tract. He may have been Mahayana coming form Vietnam, but he was interfaith serving Vietnamese, Cambodian, Laotian, and Thai Buddhist, the majority of which were Therevada. The small Vietnamese temple had a huge 15' tall statue of "Mother" a woman with white skin, possibly related to Quan Yin, the Thai temple was traditional Therevada Thai buddhas. I lived there for several months around 1990.

Ok well now to my point, this Lunpo believed in the ordination of women, and had invited two or three Buddhist nuns to live at the temple, not in white, but full orange brown robes, they lived in a mobile home seperate from the monks quarters, the thing I don't know for sure is whether they were ordained in Mahayana or Therevada tradition, and where their ordination occured, unfortunately I knew so little about the absolute rarity of this situation, I never thought to question them about the circumstances of their ordination.

But yes, I believe the order of nuns has already been re-established, its just a matter of not everyone recognizing them, I haven't heard stories of them being ridiculed or disrespected for being nuns, just not everyone accepts that they actually are nuns, as many of them don't believe in nuns. Very much like women Christian or Catholic priests or ministers, they exist but are not universally accepted.
18 years ago I made one of the most important decisions of my life and entered a local Cambodian Buddhist Temple as a temple boy and, for only 3 weeks, an actual Therevada Buddhist monk. I am not a scholar, great meditator, or authority on Buddhism, but Buddhism is something I love from the Bottom of my heart. It has taught me sobriety, morality, peace, and very importantly that my suffering is optional, and doesn't have to run my life. I hope to give back what little I can to the Buddhist community, sincerely former monk John

http://trickleupeconomictheory.blogspot.com/
User avatar
Bhikkhu Pesala
Posts: 4644
Joined: Thu Jan 29, 2009 8:17 pm

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by Bhikkhu Pesala »

David N. Snyder wrote:After I am gone, the Sangha, if it wants, may abolish the lesser and minor training rules.” Digha Nikaya 16
This has nothing to do with the legal procedures required to make an ordination valid. It is about the training rules to be followed by monastics once they have been ordained. The 500 Arahants decided not to abolish any because there was no consensus as to which they were. The topic is discussed in the Milindapañha.

Minor and Lesser Precepts
BlogPāli FontsIn This Very LifeBuddhist ChroniclesSoftware (Upasampadā: 24th June, 1979)
Nyana
Posts: 2233
Joined: Tue Apr 27, 2010 11:56 am

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by Nyana »

lyndon taylor wrote:I don't know for sure is whether they were ordained in Mahayana or Therevada tradition....
Just to clarify: The Mahāyāna isn't an ordination lineage. There are three extant ordination lineages: the Theravāda, the Dharmaguptaka, and the Mūlasarvāstivāda, all of which have descended from the ancient Sthaviras of the second council, and are therefore Sthaviravāda. Of these three, the Dharmaguptaka still has an intact bhikkhunī ordination lineage, and the Theravāda bhikkhunī ordination lineage has been reinstated.
Nyana
Posts: 2233
Joined: Tue Apr 27, 2010 11:56 am

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by Nyana »

dhammabum wrote:Thanissaro Bhikkhu makes mention that the Buddha didn't hand down a mechanism in which to revive the Sangha if it ever died, such as the Bhikkhuni Sangha. What structural constraints described in the Vinaya prevents its revival?
According to Ven. Bodhi here, there isn't any clear prohibition preventing it:
  • Further, if we pay close attention to the wording of the Vinaya passage concerned with bhikkhunī ordination, we would notice that the text does not lock this rite into a fixed and immutable form sealed with inviolable imperatives: "You must do it in this way and never in any other way." In fact, grammatically, the Pāli passage uses, not the imperious imperative, but the gentler gerundive or optative participle, "it should be done thus." But grammar aside, the text is simply describing the normal and most natural way to conduct the ordination when all the normal requisite conditions are at hand. There is nothing in the text itself, or elsewhere in the Pāli Vinaya, that lays down a rule stating categorically that, should the Bhikkhunī Sangha become extinct, the bhikkhus are prohibited from falling back on the original allowance the Buddha gave them to ordain bhikkhunīs and confer upasampadā on their own to resuscitate the Bhikkhunī Sangha.

    To me this seems to be the crucial point: Only if there were such a clear prohibition would we be entitled to say that the bhikkhus are overstepping the bounds of legitimacy by conducting such an ordination. In the absence of such a decree in the text of the Vinaya Piṭaka and its commentaries, the judgment that an ordination by bhikkhus is in violation of the Vinaya is only an interpretation.
User avatar
lyndon taylor
Posts: 1835
Joined: Mon May 02, 2011 11:41 pm
Location: Redlands, US occupied Northern Mexico
Contact:

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by lyndon taylor »

Nyana wrote:
lyndon taylor wrote:I don't know for sure is whether they were ordained in Mahayana or Therevada tradition....
Just to clarify: The Mahāyāna isn't an ordination lineage. There are three extant ordination lineages: the Theravāda, the Dharmaguptaka, and the Mūlasarvāstivāda, all of which have descended from the ancient Sthaviras of the second council, and are therefore Sthaviravāda. Of these three, the Dharmaguptaka still has an intact bhikkhunī ordination lineage, and the Theravāda bhikkhunī ordination lineage has been reinstated.

My mistake, what I meant to say is I don't know if the nuns were trained in a Mahayana or Therevada tradition, and I know that the lunpo of the monastery, while primarily catering to Therevada members, accepted people from all Buddhist faiths, not just Therevada, I have a vague recollection that one of the nuns was refered to as anila, which would imply Tibetan?? background. The point is even if the nuns started out in a Mahayana tradition, they were being allowed to live at a primarily Therevada temple in 1990, which is kind of ground breaking. I do remember being told that the Lunpo(leader) was being quite liberal to allow nuns at the temple.
18 years ago I made one of the most important decisions of my life and entered a local Cambodian Buddhist Temple as a temple boy and, for only 3 weeks, an actual Therevada Buddhist monk. I am not a scholar, great meditator, or authority on Buddhism, but Buddhism is something I love from the Bottom of my heart. It has taught me sobriety, morality, peace, and very importantly that my suffering is optional, and doesn't have to run my life. I hope to give back what little I can to the Buddhist community, sincerely former monk John

http://trickleupeconomictheory.blogspot.com/
User avatar
gavesako
Posts: 1794
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2009 5:16 pm

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by gavesako »

See the very detailed analysis here:

The first part of Ven­er­a­ble Phra Payutto’s book ‘The Bud­dhist Dis­ci­pline in Rela­tion to Bhikkhu­nis: Ques­tions & Answers: Phra Payutto & Dr. Mar­tin Seeger’ is now available.

http://www.buddhistteachings.org/the-bu ... bhikkhunis

:reading:
Bhikkhu Gavesako
Kiṃkusalagavesī anuttaraṃ santivarapadaṃ pariyesamāno... (MN 26)

Access to Insight - Theravada texts
Ancient Buddhist Texts - Translations and history of Pali texts
Dhammatalks.org - Sutta translations
User avatar
Mr Man
Posts: 4016
Joined: Tue Oct 04, 2011 8:42 am

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by Mr Man »

Ven­er­a­ble Gavesako, what is Ven­er­a­ble Phra Payutto’s conclusion to the question in the OP (if there is one)?
:anjali:
User avatar
gavesako
Posts: 1794
Joined: Sun Jan 04, 2009 5:16 pm

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by gavesako »

It is not an easy Either/Or reply that you get from P.A. Payutto. He is very carefully reviewing all the reasons for establishing the various Vinaya rules and the historical developments during the Buddha's lifetime, but he says that it is not up to him to make some final decision on this point now.
Bhikkhu Gavesako
Kiṃkusalagavesī anuttaraṃ santivarapadaṃ pariyesamāno... (MN 26)

Access to Insight - Theravada texts
Ancient Buddhist Texts - Translations and history of Pali texts
Dhammatalks.org - Sutta translations
User avatar
Zom
Posts: 2707
Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 6:38 pm
Location: Russia, Saint-Petersburg
Contact:

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by Zom »

The first part of Ven­er­a­ble Phra Payutto’s book ‘The Bud­dhist Dis­ci­pline in Rela­tion to Bhikkhu­nis: Ques­tions & Answers: Phra Payutto & Dr. Mar­tin Seeger’ is now available.

http://www.buddhistteachings.org/the-bu ... bhikkhunis
Thanks for the text.
As I found out, Ven. Payutto shares the same thoughts as I had some time ago while thinking about the matter (especially about "making just more confusion").
User avatar
yamaka
Posts: 101
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2010 8:44 am
Location: Malaysia
Contact:

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by yamaka »

I have no offense to these nuns,but don't you feeling funny when you are trying to mix up the dharmaguptaka order with the theravada?
User avatar
now realm
Posts: 47
Joined: Sat Apr 13, 2013 9:23 am
Location: Malaysia

Re: Can the Bhikkhuni Sangha be revived as per the Vinaya?

Post by now realm »

I also have no issue too with bhikkhuni ordination in the Theravada lineage that was established by the Buddha if there's solid & valid legitimate grounds. However, the original lineage is no more in existence according to the history in Theravada Buddhism. I also find that the dharmagupta is more of a Mahayana or other lineages than Theravada. Also, was it the Buddha's intention to establish a Bhikkhuni Order? If so, why did he object to his aunt's request three times resoundingly? He would have told Ven. Ananda that it was his intention & there was no need for garudhamma to be imposed in the order. Unfortunately, I don't think anyone can revive an extinct lineage. An example is dinosaurs are extinct after many thousands of years in existence. Can then dinosours be revived? Buddha said everything exists, become & die out. Pls ignore, if what I said here is wrong due to my own interpretation or view & my lack of knowledge on this issue. Be calm.. :-)
Post Reply